Alexander Calvert
Jack Kline / Belphegor
Felicia Day
Charlie Bradbury
Rob Benedict
Chuck Shurley / God
Richard Speight, Jr
The Trickster / Gabriel / Loki
Matt Cohen
Young John Winchester
Ruth Connell
Rowena
Kim Rhodes
Sheriff Jody Mills
Briana Buckmaster
Sheriff Donna Hanscum
Adam Fergus
Mick Davies
David Haydn-Jones
Arthur Ketch
Sebastian Roché
Balthazar